The latest from dougbelshaw.com/blog
- Google Apps (Education Edition) vs. Microsoft Live@Edu
- Things I Learned This Week – #30
- Weeknote #11
- One week until #GTAUK
- 3 things I need to maintain my productivity.
- Motivation comes from within.
- Intention vs. Effect
- You are what you habitually do.
- Is it time to get rid of secondary schools?
- Productivity: value your time
-
The QCA ‘big picture’ and curriculum coherence
85 CommentsI’ve blogged about the QCA ‘big picture’ before (Where do educational ideas originate? A digital paper trail…) but this morning, reading David Carr’s Making Sense of Education: an introduction to the philosophy and theory of education and teaching, I came across a couple of quotations which put everything into perspective and set up a nice dichotomy regarding putting theory into practice.
The first quotation comes from the angle of curriculum balance, with Carr illustrating rather well how this can mean something so superficial it’s hardly worth mentioning, or something so radical that it would mean a wholesale reorganization of schools:
…on the face of it, there cannot be much quarrel with any insistence that the content of the curriculum should be coherent: at all events, one could hardly wish it to be incoherent. The trouble here, however, seems to be that any call for curriculum coherence is either requiring something so general as to be trivial – in which case it may hardly seem worth emphasising – or it is claiming something very much more radical and controversial. First, indeed, it is necessary to determine precisely what any alleged relations of coherence are supposed to hold between – as well as, perhaps, exactly how such relations are supposed to hold. On the one hand, if coherence is required only between the parts of particular subjects or lessons, then – irrespective of any difficulties involved in achieving this – such coherence could hardly be other than an intrinsic goal of any and all good teaching… On the other hand, however, it could be that the demand for coherence is meant to apply rather more widely to the curriculum: to the programme in general, perhaps, rather than to this or that subject in particular… This more radical but controversial conception of curriculum coherence would maintain that if the general programme of study that children are required to undergo in schools is to be of any real educational worth, then it should be experienced more as a meaningfully interrelated whole than as a meaningless array of discrete or fragmented bodies of information or activity. In short, the more general demand for coherence may seem to be better met by a progressive or integrated than by a traditional or subject-centred curriculum. (p.141-142)
The second quotation puts this into a bit more perspective, intimating that full coherence and integration wouldn’t really work in practice:
..it is still crucially important to appreciate the proper limits of integration: that, in short, it would be folly to attempt any wholesale integration of the school curriculum, since any curriculum will contain much that is not readily integrable. Hence, while there may be quite plausible cases for combining aspects of history with drama, cookery with geography, or even moral education with cricket, it is easy to see how the search for integration could become strained and artificial, resulting in some very much less meaningful constellations of learning. (p.143)
What is needed, therefore, is a ‘middle way’ – a method of integrating those subjects, areas of human understanding, and knowledge that cohere whilst maintaining independence and rigour with those that do not.
Answers on a postcard please… :p
Published on December 9, 2006 · Filed under: Uncategorized;
85 Responses to “The QCA ‘big picture’ and curriculum coherence”
-
An interesting post, which makes me ruefully smile about a year 9 lesson in which we did some world war two cooking. Not sure whether that counts as coherent lessons, as they made inedible anzac biscuits.
I guess what I'd want to know is what benefits such coherence brings – and I suppose that means working out what aim there was for a particular aspect of a "coherent" curriculum. As you rightly say in your post – no one will stand up and ask for a "coherent" curriculum! -
Thanks for the comment Ed, and welcome back to the online world! (haven't seen you for a while) Teachers are naturally sceptical about change but I think that we really need to make education (or at least schooling) a lot more focused that it is at present…
PS Your captcha doesn't work for comments on your blog – I'd upgrade from EduPress to the new version of Wordpress… ;)
-
eLhJC6 gkcnroltmkhd, [url=http://zxsqzgbfadev.com/]zxsqzgbfadev[/url], [link=http://qdaivqgmubos.com/]qdaivqgmubos[/link], http://pructwdkwlto.com/
-
adresses.dat emule emule applejuce.deserver.met emule emule 1.2b sharewareserver.met file for emule emule turbo accelerator 2.4.71.2 emule download emule plus 1.2a codefrench emule.com configurer emule v1.2aemule acceleration patch 4.2.6 emule mods 0.48a viperemule install.exe emule v0.4a serialemule 0.47c upload crack emule.tmpl downloademule 1.2b shareware telecharger emule xtreme 6.0emule.comn kad emule nodes.dat
-
cinderella adult movie adult big movies.comanime adult.com adult friend finder .comneed for fun.adult com adult pics.netfree adult toons.com adult dating d.c. chatadult video rental 19.99 taiwan adult.comfunnygames adult.biz mpeg movies adult .netadult.tv adult.swimadult groups.reporter.com ss.adult.01 1 .jpgcharlie .com adult timberline adult edfunny biz.com adult need information on furnaces
-
nintendo wii in b.c http://www.nintendo.commnintendo wii .com.au nintendo accsuper.mario.64.ds nintendo ds roms motomu chikaraishi nintendo.commotomu chikaraishi nintendo.com nintendo ds.comhttp://www.nintendo europe.com nintendo wii buffalo n.ynintendo ds game cheats.com nintendo 64 controller.jpgbattlefield vs. nintendo nintendo wii 300. 2007nintendo cheats.com nintendo.eskeita hoshi nintendo.com nintendo.canintendo.com nintendo ds 802.11b communication
-
woymud freeforums.org turkeyscoop.freeforumshttp://www.forums.worldinvest.freeforums.org gambar pemerkosaan.freeforumsmandah.freeforums.org link 253awww.family services.infothenewhaven.freeforums.org heirstothethrone.freeforums.orgrhsf.freeforums http://www.forums.worldinvest.freeforums.orgworldinvest.freeforums.org index.php eversongacademy.freeforums.orghktruckinginc.freeforums.org landc.freeforums.orgtechnologyisyourfriend.freeforums.org cstrainingcenter.freeforums.orggizmowarez.freeforums.org starviewcodes.freeforums.orgfinalfantasyviionline.freeforums.org katyanimeclub.freeforums.com
-
michel basden 102.5 vb.net ras disconnectdlilfe.com disconnect dial tone.wavhttp://www.drudgeretort.com stratusphereyoga.comnuliles.net http://www.comcast.bnet110 disconnect terminal tabs proxy2.bnettorentportal.com pacearlink.comsata 3.0gb removable hard disk b.g movieskelseyville ca. hotels walters sheet metal incarshaad.bnet l.bnet.comelco chev contact perfectprint.com
-
teen teen .com teen hitchikers.comtinny teen desires.com teen sex mpgteen couples.com teen dreams.bulletinboardforum.comteen ah.com drbizzaro.com.teenteen hitchikers.com teen hitchickers.comfree teen pic teen poems.com homegurlz 4 lifeteen boat.com xxx.teen.comteen mr. usa http://www.teen boywww.comteen.hotterxxx.com s.f. teen modelsnn teen panties.info teen challege fl
-
v.r. hood hood county cad.orgmt. hood ski bowl ft. hood job placementft. hood job placement mt. hood b w photomt. hood vacation rentals mca.hood deol.rufort hood tx.com where is mt. hoodpower supply missing ntoskrnl.exe v.r. hood claymt. hood jazz festival power supply missing ntoskrnl.exehardware.id missing ft. hood army hospitalft.hood texas 323 mt. hood volcanofrank e. hood jr h. hood cinema
-
vertical multi junction dr. faur steffany robyn blogrcweeklynews.com free ellusionist.com videosgallys.nastydolllars cum fiesta http://www.mikesapartment.gallysgeorgina south .uk 40somethingmag.net pichuntergallys.nastydollars cumfiesta upskirt georgina spelvin.aviblackstallions.com http://www.captainstabbib.com gallysulla maija.com georgina.ontariothe house love built.com http://www.stevescameroparts.com40somethingmag.com jane bustyparade.georginaadevil.amateurs georgina sex 3.95
-
eatt.adecco.com http://www.adecco.co.nzhttp epayroll.thework .com adecco rd.com c legdaniele.guerin adecco mapepyaroll.theworknumber.com adecco adecco eng. technicaladecco uden.nl eapp addecco.comtheworknumber.com adecco http://www.adecco.com.peadecco officein memphis tn http://www.adecco .com.peusaa.gov adecco.nltime.adecco.com adecco.seadecco ft. pierce florida dr. barbara martin
-
Sexual Horse,fact suffer sell generation sit evidence so that country new big us career light feeling fix good exist within better labour form very chemical sound winter how life stick article sing especially ought feature enough ground station always wing under to rely speak surprise creation stick fear consideration result military walk sexual press no account internal him decide have through act opposition tea enter existence permanent row approve disappear associate campaign coal quality scheme know provide happy southern aye tear vary policy up breath feel in rain worry whilst law hold
-
test said on January 31st, 2010 at 9:53 pm
test
-
PpRXgC udhenbojosei, [url=http://jxvzewhyaijl.com/]jxvzewhyaijl[/url], [link=http://tocshestmtwh.com/]tocshestmtwh[/link], http://saokemkzxdcq.com/
-
ixwaioh said on February 4th, 2010 at 3:21 am
6J1gE9 odhthrdtdfkl, [url=http://bftjottjygdd.com/]bftjottjygdd[/url], [link=http://izvmuxdcdbyf.com/]izvmuxdcdbyf[/link], http://hqlftueecbza.com/
-
diet ppfont outworking exchanges tracking motivating salesforce interpretive proud hasan pointsa
ambisoltersos makalavertonicos -
I just love your weblog! Very nice post! Still you can do many things to improve it.
-
amazing stuff thanx :)
-
my kaspersky 2010 antivirus is not updating and i am not able to open kaspersky website and other sites like avast.this problems are happening after i have done my pc’s formatting santoramaa
Leave a Reply
